Get A Free Consultation
interior of modern restaurant

Nestled just a short drive north of Columbus, Ohio, the charming suburb of Worthington offers more than just picturesque streets and a rich history. It’s also a culinary gem with an impressive array of restaurants that cater to diverse tastes and preferences. 

Whether you’re a local looking to expand your dining horizons or a visitor seeking a delightful culinary experience, Worthington has something for everyone. In this blog post, we’ll take you on a gastronomic journey through the best restaurants in Worthington, Ohio, showcasing their menus and what makes each of them a must-visit.

1) The Whitney House

Our culinary tour of Worthington begins with The Whitney House, a beloved establishment known for its warm ambiance and delectable farm-to-table cuisine. This charming restaurant is a perfect blend of modern and rustic, offering a cozy dining experience that’s ideal for both casual dinners and special occasions.

Menu Highlights:

  • Starters: Try their mouthwatering whipped goat cheese dip with grilled farmhouse bread or the Crispy Brussels Sprouts with fried capers and parmesan.
  • Main Courses: Indulge in the Pan-Seared Salmon with lemon butter or the Braised Short Rib Sliders with housemade potato chips.
  • Desserts: Don’t miss the decadent olive oil cake with an orange-blackberry caramel sauce and fresh cream.

⭐️ 4.6 on Google

📍666 High St, Worthington, OH 43085

☎️ (614) 396-7846

2) J. Gilbert’s Wood-Fired Steaks & Seafood

If you’re a fan of succulent steaks and fresh seafood, J. Gilbert’s is the place to be. This upscale steakhouse offers a luxurious dining experience with a menu that showcases the finest cuts of meat and the freshest catches of the day.

Menu Highlights:

  • Steaks: Choose from a variety of cuts, including Filet Mignon, Kansas City Strip, and Bone-In Ribeye, all cooked to perfection.
  • Seafood: Enjoy the maple plank roasted salmon with a bourbon glaze or the Lobster Tail with drawn butter.
  • Sides: Don’t forget to order the Lobster Mac & Cheese or the Poblano Au Gratin Potatoes.

⭐️ 4.5 on Google

📍1 E Campus View Blvd, Columbus, OH 43235

☎️ (614) 840-9090

3) Northstar Café

For those looking for a more health-conscious dining option, Northstar Café is a top choice. This restaurant emphasizes sustainability and locally sourced ingredients, resulting in a menu that’s as nourishing as it is delicious.

Menu Highlights:

  • Burgers: Try their Northstar Veggie Burger, made from black beans, brown rice, and beets. Want something meatier? The classic cheeseburger with Ohio-raised beef and smoked cheddar should tickle your fancy!
  • Salads: Opt for the Buddha Bowl with tofu, brown rice, and seasonal vegetables or the Beechwold Chopped Salad with avocado and goat cheese.
  • Brunch: Don’t miss their famous Cloud Nine Pancakes or the Big Burrito with scrambled eggs, black beans, and guacamole.

⭐️ 4.5 on Google

📍4241 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214

☎️ (614) 784-2233

4) Pies and Pints

Is there anything better than pizza? Well, how about pizza and an ice-cold beer? If you are looking for a delicious meal, look no further than Pies and Pints. With house-made dough, gluten-free options, and featured breweries, you’re sure to have an incredible experience!

Menu Highlights:

  • Appetizers: Start with the pizza skins – garlic mashed potatoes, cheddar, scallions, and bacon on the signature pizza dough.
  • Entrees: You can’t miss the signature house pizzas, such as the grape and gorgonzola, Nashville hot chicken, and Sriracha Shrimp!
  • Desserts: You can’t go wrong with the chocolate peanut butter brownie terrine, topped with a layer of chocolate ganache.

⭐️ 4.5 on Google

📍7227 N High St, Worthington, OH 43085

☎️ (614) 885-7437

5) La Chatelaine French Bakery & Bistro

Transport yourself to the enchanting streets of France right in the heart of Worthington at La Chatelaine French Bakery & Bistro. This family-owned gem offers an authentic taste of French cuisine, from flaky croissants to savory quiches.

Menu Highlights:

  • Breakfast: Enjoy a breakfast sandwich on a fresh croissant or the Parisian Omelette with ham, mushroom, and Swiss.
  • Lunch: You can’t miss the hearty and comforting boeuf bourguignon or the classic croque monsieur with bechamel sauce.
  • Pastries: Don’t leave without trying their Éclairs or Fruit Tarts.

⭐️ 4.4 on Google

📍627 High St, Worthington, OH 43085

☎️ (614) 848-6711

6) Villa Nova Ristorante

If you’re in the mood for Italian cuisine, Villa Nova Ristorante has been serving up classic dishes with a modern twist for over five decades. This family-owned restaurant offers a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and a menu filled with Italian favorites.

Menu Highlights:

  • Pasta: Indulge in the Spaghetti Carbonara or the Gnocchi with housemade meatballs
  • Entrees: Keep it simple with a sirloin steak or breaded perch dinner platter.
  • Desserts: Satisfy your sweet tooth with the Tiramisu or the Snickers Cannoli.

⭐️ 4.6 on Google

📍5545 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214

☎️ (614) 846-5777

7) Aladdin’s Eatery

Enjoy the fresh food and outstanding service at Aladdin’s Eatery when you visit Worthington! This incredible eatery offers authentic Lebanese food, with plenty of options for vegetarians, vegans, and meat eaters alike!

Menu Highlights:

  • Delicious Pitas: Pita bread takes the spotlight at this restaurant, with pita pizzas and sandwiches.
  • Appetizers: Make sure to try the dawali – grape leaves stuffed with rice and chickpeas and topped with creamy feta.
  • Healthy Salads – Fresh greens are topped with a variety of toppings, including juicy chicken, salty olives, and delicious spices.

⭐️ 4.4 on Google

📍7227 N High St #106, Worthington, OH 43085

☎️ (614) 430-1730

While You Eat Well, We Work Hard

There are certainly no shortages when it comes to quality Worthington restaurants. From upscale steakhouses to cozy farm-to-table eateries and authentic French bistros, Worthington offers a diverse range of dining experiences to suit all tastes. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, these restaurants are sure to satisfy your cravings and leave you with unforgettable culinary memories.

While you are supporting one local business, let our local business support you! At Best Exteriors, we offer a full range of home exterior services, including roofing, siding, and gutters. Contact us today to set up your free consultations. 

Drew Paetow

We’ll have you love your home project so much that people will drive by and comment on how good it looks. That is our promise to you.

Recent Articles

Work with Best & Forget the rest